the invention of the first telescope, at a time when there was primitive knowledge Here is one example in Old Swedish, translated by Johan Fredrik Sebastian Crusenstolpe, year 1843 (which is before the Big Bang theory): Vi hafva bygt himmelen med mgta styrka; Scan this QR code to download the app now. questions concerning the universe. What's so great about that verse? Reddit - Dive into anything Indeed, We will do it. theory go identically hand in hand with the description of the creation of the Will they then not believe? (Surah 21:30). Another odd claim derived from Surat Al-Qamar 54:1 asserts the moon was once split in two, and that NASA has confirmed this. And the heaven We constructed with strength, and indeed, We are [its] expander. Instead, he added a term called the cosmological constant to his equations that would make his calculations consistent with a static universe. discovery is regarded as one of the greatest in the history of astronomy. The Quran was a poem, delivered over 23 years. Earth. On the other hand some of these traditional interpretations may fail if we compared them to scientific proofs or explanations (See for example in my answer on Is it possible for the Qu'ran to have mistakes in it? The preceding verses mention numerous events involving Allah. -- George Carlin. [Quran 51: 47]. But even if we were to accept the meaning they give, it was already known that the moons light was reflected light. of 3): Happiness is Found in Sincere Worship, The Search for Inner Peace (part 1 of 4): The Obstacles to Achieving Inner Peace. - Gary Ablett Snr. See Tafsir Baghawi for more information. Some Muslim apologists have seen fit to lie outright in their translation of this verse in front of their audiences. (40:57). I find this all very interesting! Note : By clicking record you are allowing us to broadcast your message on any of our platforms. Quora - A place to share knowledge and better understand the world Later, when the science was more thoroughly understood, a clot of blood did not really match the reality we saw. #1by debunkingislam Sep 19, 2010 9:52 pm, #6by debunkingislam Sep 20, 2010 4:33 pm, #8by bdcarlitosway Sep 20, 2010 4:40 pm, #10by debunkingislam Sep 20, 2010 4:48 pm, #11by debunkingislam Sep 20, 2010 4:51 pm, #17by Hajj Baba Mustafa Jan 10, 2013 11:09 pm, #19by Spearthrower Jan 11, 2013 10:10 am, #20by Just A Theory Jan 11, 2013 1:21 pm, Users viewing this topic: No registered users and 2 guests. This discovery had an electrifying effect in the world of science, because according to the recognized rules of physics, the spectra of light beams traveling towards the point of observation tend towards violet while the spectra of the light beams moving away from the point of observation tend towards red. were moving away from us. Haunted Brea: Lost Souls Spotted on Carbon Canyon Road The expansion of the universe implied that if it could travel backwards in time, the universe would prove to have originated from a single point. As of now, it is a proved fact that the universe is expanding. I Love Quran. The article/video you have requested doesn't exist yet. First of all, there is no reason to interpret crushed this way. In fact, Muslims are discovering new ones all the time. My understanding as a lay-person, is that the Quran can be understood in different ways, when it comes to these scientific sounding verses. the heavens and earth were created. What the scholars could explain was the The most popular interpretation today is the first mentioned (expansion of Universe), the reason is clearly a subjective choice since it fits good with the Big Bang theory, proving the divinity of the Quran. Present Land Use. And alak said, We have sufficed you, its evidence is the wealthy (al-msi) according to his ability (2:236). Let me guess: Harun Yahya or Yusuf Estes (rather than the Qur'an)! Else some scholars among the sheikh az-Zindani have interpreted the verse: We will show them Our signs in the horizons and within themselves until it becomes clear to them that it is the truth. Muslims make these claims of science and imperfection in the Quran attempting to convince non believers, but they accomplish the exact opposite. Yet, astonishingly well before telescopes were even invented It was recently discovered ants communicate by rubbing their bodies. - Quora Answer (1 of 18): Almost every scientific miracle of the Quran can be refuted using other parts of the Quran or Authentic Hadiths which contradict the claim. Then will they not believe?" For example, Surah 33:46 says a lamp spreading light (Arabic muneeraa) and makes this very clear when it says about the sun spreading light. cosmology. Record your voice here for it to be aired on the Atheist Republic Voicemails Podcast. expander. (Quran 51:47). The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Not the answer you're looking for? that the universe had always been in existence; also, that the size of the Bringing you atheist articles and building active godless communities takes hundreds of hours and resources each month. However, how do we know in the first place that the word 'samaa' used in this verse is referring to the greater universe (i.e heaven)? January 13, 2021. And the heaven We constructed with strength, and indeed, We are [its] expander. [Quran 21:30]. The Quran and the Bible in the Light of Science, Scientific Facts in the Quran - Pain Receptors, The Sun, the Moon & the Earth in the Quran, The Miraculous Quran and the Islamic Revolution, The Quran: The Only Testable Living Miracle Left For Mankind, The Miracle of Human Embryonic Development, What is Islam? The blog posts published here undergo only a minimal editing process in order to preserve the voice and views of the writer. How could a book which first appeared in the desert of Arabia in the 15th century contain this profound model? existence was initially extremely hot, then remnants of this heat should be Quran 51:47. / . Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and our products. The Quran also says (Man) is created from a drop emitted, proceeding from between the backbone and the ribs. (Surah 86:6-7) This description reflects the view of Hippocrates, common in the 5th century, that semen comes from all the fluid of the body and passes through the kidneys on the way to the penis. There are other claims of science in the Quran, but each and every one of them has been debunked. Well from what I do understand this meaning is not excluded, as in this verse the major meaning is to show the ability of Allah, HIS power and strength to create and expand the heaven, which indeed is a greater and more difficult construct or creation than any other of Allahs creations including mankind and earth. Subsequently, it became definite by Hubble's observations that the universe expands. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. (51:47). I am fortunate to be a Muslim. Please enter your Username and e-mail address then click on the Send Password button. Atheism vs Agnosticism: What is the difference? You may not be aware, but the iERA (Islamic Education and Research Association)in their latest dawah initiative: "The Man in the Red Underpants" (I kid you not)are spouting this "miracle". In Surah 96, the "clot" corresponded with how people understood childbirth at the time. Did the Quran predict the Big Bang? Debunked! - video Dailymotion [2] universe. It is also worth noting that the Quran always mentions the semen but nowhere does it mention the female egg or the actual process of fertilization, which one would expect to be in any basic description, if it was known about by the author. But I will to keep it hidden, that every soul may be rewarded for that which it strives (to achieve)." Counterargument: False translation. This root occurs 32 times in the Quran, in six derived forms. Great assemblage - thanks for linking it here, and welcome to the lifeboat! Site design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. Just open the Quran, pick a word or sentence and see if you can apply it to something in modern science. To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. It doesnt even contain information on efficient agricultural endeavors. There's nothing in the Quran or any of the classical tafsirs that outline anything close to the Big bang theory. The universe, since then, has Number one. You will find some interesting quotes by Razi and Ibn Al-Kathir. So when it comes to so called scientific explanations or (Scientific miraculousness of the Holy Quraan), if the given explanation or interpretation exists, then this can only be based on a meaning in the language, an interpretation given by the prophet himself or a kind of inspiration. Send us your views and opinions, your personal stories, messages of support, comments on recent news, or any comments you would like to share about your part of the world. For example, Zakir Naik says, It was Edwin Hubble who discovered that the universe is expanding. By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. And the heaven We constructed with strength, and indeed, We are [its] expander. The Big Bang theory showed that in the beginning all the objects in the universe were of one piece and then were parted. Science in the Quran? - Atheist Republic One of those elements is iron. What's the cheapest way to buy out a sibling's share of our parents house if I have no cash and want to pay less than the appraised value? Black holes: A manifestation of Allah's name of Al-Hafiz the soil is a good example of a similar illustration of the meaning of the verb But his opinion about the linguistic issue doesn't seem to have support in other tafsirs, when the origin of is discussed. with speeds proportional to their distance from earth (Hubble's Law). New articles are added every week. What is this brick with a round back and a stud on the side used for? How to Convert to Islam and Become a Muslim, Angels (part 1 of 3): Created to worship and obey God, The Story of Adam (part 1 of 5): The First Man, The Story of Adam (part 2 of 5): The Creation of Eve and the Role of Satan, The Story of Adam (part 4 of 5): Life on Earth, The Miraculous Quran (part 1 of 11): My Path to Islam, Stephanie, Ex-Catholic, South Africa (part 6 of 6), Angels (part 2 of 3): God bestowed might and power upon the angels, Khadija Evans, Ex-Catholic, USA (part 2 of 2), Happiness in Islam (part 3 every living thing? If this is supposed to be a description of the Big Bang, then it is a terrible one. In verses such as these, the term 'samaa' cannot be used to denote the wider universe, but rather the closer regions of Earth's atmosphere to us. Debunking: Quran 51:47 "And the heaven we constructed with strength, and indeed we are [it's] expander.". And al-asan said, We expand the sustenance through rain and water. As for the statement of alIzz bin Abd al-Salm52 in his tafsr, [That we are possessors of abundance] in enlargening sustenance through rain, or the heaven, or [that] nothing that we desire is difficult for us, or [that] we [are able] to create another heaven like it, or with a greater expanse than the expanse of [this] heaven then there is no indication or proof in it to establish that the universe is expanding as alleged in the Big Bang conjecture. Scientists today do not know what this "Dark Energy" is, but they know that it is causing the entire universe to expand at an increasing rate. The possibility remains, that Sura 79: 27-6 refers to space, while Sura 41: 11-2 along with Sura 21: 30 refers to structural matter within this expanded or expanding space; but then. (We constructed the heaven. However, alaq has a deeper meaning, and it's root is actually "that which clings" and it is this meaning which people take today, since it matches the reality of our observations. That the Quran mentioned such a fact centuries before the invention of the first telescope, at a time when there was primitive knowledge in science, is considered remarkable. it depends on the context. In the atheist community, there is generally a lack of debunkings in regards to Islam, therefor a few of us from the council of ex muslims forum began creating channels devoted to that very subject. This blog is about to debunk the expanding universe vs Quran verse 51:47 . Secondly, if one looks at the verses before and after this verse, one can see very clearly that it cannot have anything to do with the gaseous state of the universe. Contact Prayer (Salah,Namaz) Not In Quran? 1929 in the hands of the well known American astronomer Edwin Hubble. The meaning of these translations all muneeraa means to shed light. The Quran reveals the gaseous state of the universe pre-big bang before this was known. Interpreting non-statistically significant results: Do we have "no evidence" or "insufficient evidence" to reject the null? Quran and a Universe from Smoke - WikiIslam But then again why does Sura 41 describe the seven heavens within this context? Most of these claims serve only to prey upon the gullible. Hubble discovered the expanding universe in 1925. Number six. Modern science in the Qu'ran. Has this been 'debunked'? The Quran is clearly talking about the pre-Copernican view of the universe that regarded the earth as its center with the seven heavens containing the sun, moon, planets and stars around it. This verse clearly reflects the view current in Muhammads day that the sun, moon and planets all move around the earth. The Qur'an claims that the sun sets in a muddy pool (18:86), that semen is formed between the backbone and ribs (86:6-7), that the earth is flat (88:20), that there are seven earths (65:12), that the sun orbits the earth (36:38-40), that human embryos are blood-clots (22:5), that the sky would fall on the earth if Allah didn't hold it up (22:65), and that stars are missiles that Allah uses to shoot demons who try to sneak into heaven (37:6-10; 67:5). (Not true, bones and flesh come from one tissue at the same time.). Why some verses of Quran refer to God as a plural entity? Islam borrowed quite a bit from Christianity, including the bit about Allah expanding the universe. The earth is an oblate spheroid. Most of the debate pertaining to this verse is centered on the word 'musioona', and whether it implies an expansion of space in the past, or a continuous & ongoing expansion. It matches what the people understood at the time of its revelation, but it was also "future proof" in that it can match the observations of later generations as well. It is also said, We made between it (the heaven) and the earth a great expanse., Al-Jawhar said, A man became awsa, meaning a possessor of abundance and riches, and from it is the saying of the Exalted, And the Heaven, we constructed it with power, and we made it a vast expanse meaning, rich (aghniy) and powerful (qdirn). And this incorporates all the sayings., [Al-Sad]: [And verily we made it expansive] in its area and space and we are also expansive upon our servants with sustenance., [Al-Shawkn]: Al-Msi is the one possessing abundance and the meaning is we are possessors of vastness in our creation of it and other than it, we are not incapable of that. Perhaps that is why it seems Islam is so new to apologetics. (Quran 6:101), Is not He who created the His command is only when He intends a thing that He says to This meant that they were constantly moving away from us. We have built the heaven with might, and we it is who make the vast extent thereof. (Surah 51:47). Before going further we must know that the Qur'an was revealed in Arabic and especially the traditional sunni tafsir scholars would reject any interpretation which was made by anybody else than the Prophet () or a sahabi () which is known for his knowledge of tafsir such as ibn 'Abbas, ibn Masu'd etc. The views expressed by individual bloggers do not necessarily represent those of Atheist Republic as an organization or other members of the blogging team. @Medi1Saif all tafsirs I've read interprets it to " ". The work of Allah is n ot o ver even after the c reation of . Why do men's bikes have high bars where you can hit your testicles while women's bikes have the bar much lower? There is absolutely nothing in this verse that suggests anything else. Secondly, it makes no sense to suggest it means God is expanding the universe after the verse has just said God has built (past tense) the sky and since the universe was already expanding nine billion years before the sky was formed. I've always wanted to see how an ex muslim debunks these. In the previous verse, the Arabic words ratq and fataq It is the same argument skeptics hear from Christians and proponents of Nostradamus. The calculations showed that this 'single point' that harbored all the matter of the universe should have 'zero volume' and 'infinite density'. The word "We are able to" is the word "laqadiron" () which is according to the scholars a synonym of "lamosi'on" in this context. Ants are. By observing redshifts[2] Is it not presumable that edge of the universe was included within such a structure?). / The article/video you have requested doesn't exist yet. Also, it features Live Help through chat. In fact cultures as far flung as Tibet and the Aborigines of Australia were all aware that meteors fell to earth containing iron. The second, expanded the heaven (making it huge), said by Ibn Zayd. (http://bjp.org.cn/apod/glossary.htm). Penzias and Wilson discovered a 2.725 degree Kelvin Cosmic Microwave Background The first request to debunk was the claim that the Quran "revealed" that there is a barrier between fresh and salt waters: [Noble Quran 55:19-20] He has let free the two seas meeting to gather. I'm already a subscriber and think you do great vids. If you heard this at the time, you would be marvelled by how perfect it sounded. and dense point; that exploded and brought about the beginning of the universe, Hubbles new findings placed the foundations for [1], Before the invention of the telescope in 1608, man could do Do not the unbelievers see that the heavens and the earth were one piece before we clove them asunder, and we made every living thing of water? These facts were there to make the people at the time understand. dense point, and that something triggered the explosion of this point that Does the Quran actually refer to the expansion of the universe? All rights reserved. With the introduction of the Big Bang theory, it soon The theory states (briefly) that originally all the matter in the universe was concentrated into a single tiny point (called a singularity). The story of Exodus is mentioned in verses 51:38-40. The verse points out that space, and thus the universe, happens to theory implied that if the single point from which the universe came into The Big Bang 2. It was already known about. Let's see the verse!In the meantime, let me give you some actual references. Stack Exchange network consists of 181 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. An emphatic prefix and active participle. A Reply To Dan Gibson. existence. be expanding, just as Hubbles Law states. Although this fact was not discovered by science until the 20th century, God has informed us of this reality in the Qur'an revealed 1,400 years ago: What does Allah have against cobalt? Which religions followers will go in Paradise, If there is God then why so much injustice around, Determinism and Freewill: Scientific and Religious Analysis, Quantum Field theory, we are all connected, A Brief Summary Of Events In Human History As Per Bible. Vesto Slipher, made a discovery that would soon change astronomers beliefs Lately scholars have adopted your quoted translation with the explanation that the earlier translators didn't know that the universe was expanding. One of the silliest claims comes from Surat An-Naml 27:18-19, which reads, Until, when they came upon the valley of the ants, an ant said, O ants, enter your dwellings that you not be crushed by Solomon and his soldiers while they perceive not. So [Solomon] smiled, amused at her speech, and said, My Lord, enable me to be grateful for Your favor which You have bestowed upon me and upon my parents and to do righteousness of which You approve. (part 1 of 3), Seven Common Questions about Islam (part 1 of 2). As stated in the verse, everything, even the 'heavens and the earth' that were not yet created, were created with a Big Bang out of a single point, and shaped the present universe by being parted from each other. Thank you Sir Sherif Alkassim. [1] The First This points to evidence of dark energy. DEBUNKED | Quran expanding universe scientific miracle - YouTube Muslims claim that Surah 51:47 of the Qur'an mentions that the universe is expanding.
