What happens if you use lip liner as eyeliner? In part of its findings, CIR wrote that a lack of case reports and no ongoing FDA regulatory actions suggested to the Panel that ocular injury is not likely. If, in fact, consumers sustain ocular injury from the use of PET glitter, then it seems it will fall to consumers to report those injuries to the FDA. FDA considers glitter and mica-based composite pigments to be non-permitted color additives when used in FDA-regulated products, including cosmetics. For the price this is excellent quality. We use dedicated people and clever technology to safeguard our platform. . The CIR study on polyethylene terephthalate linked in the post also looked at a few other forms, so that might be helpful, too. However, you cannot combine the discount codes with other offers on their website when placing your order. Based on reading through all three reports, the final report on PET glitter didnt seem quite as detailed or as thorough to me, so Id certainly like to see more studies/tests done. Im not here to to tell you to wear glitter or to not wear glitter. Outstanding piece, Christine. Additionally, ColourPop BFF Eyeliner contains Caprylyl Glycol, an ingredient that works as a preservative and prevents bacteria from growing to spoil the formula. It aims to provide healthier cosmetics products with significantly fewer chemicals to save the animals and promote positive change in the beauty industry. I just ordered blue contacts after 20 years of not playing with them and it was some youtubers suggestion (with code) I got them in, but they felt like they were too convaved and stood out too much on the inside of my eyelid. Your California Privacy Rights. Hey Christine! BrandRated is reader-supported. ColourPop Over the Liner Lippie Pencil ($5.00 for 0.04 oz.) Im happy to get cruelty-free, vegan products at a reasonable price.I was told about this company by my then teenage daughter. Medium, Olive, neutral undertones. Brands like NARS and Fenty have released pressed glitter eyeshadows, too, and I use the term eyeshadow because they, too, use the same term to describe those products; their palettes did not come with any warning/disclosure, and the packaging showed an eye icon. "You need to be careful around eyes; take no chances. I wore both glitter eyeshadows on part of lower lash linesnot my waterlines but below my eyelineras past personal experience has given me more irritation from glitter fallout into my eyes (often requiring early removal of a look) when Ive worn it on my lid (I had no irritation during wear, only after removal). Especially since a good amount of glittery stuff seems to be marketed heavily towards that age catchment. ColourPop partnered with Sephora stores in 2017 and expanded its availability to the retail space, and in 2018, the company partnered with the chain of beauty stores Ulta Beauty, Inc. The only way to increase safety standards (physical safety and environmental safety) is to make a lot of noise about it. Lippie Pencil - ColourPop | Ulta Beauty Colourpop ColourPop PEACH FUZZ Matte Eyeliner Retractable Pencil Creme Gel (Pastel Peach), 0.2g (0.007 Ounce) 1 Count (Pack of 1) 4.1 out of 5 stars 61. . . Curate a Makeup Collection You Love with More Mindfulness (2022 Guide), How-to Buy Less Makeup: Guide to Makeup No-Buys & Low-Buys (2022). We pride ourselves on being cruelty-free, wallet-friendly, and keeping our customers at the center of our world. The 100%-vegan-and-cruelty-free formula consists of marine ingredients that hydrate and protect your delicate under eyes. Hi Christine Our ColourPop Bronzer review found that this product contains Lauroyl Lysine, which functions as a powder emollient to enhance adherence to your skin and lessen the drying effects of the powders used to make this bronzer. The products I removed immediately prior to something getting stuck in my eye area were Fenty eyeshadows from the Rose and Pastel Frost palettes, Marc Jacobs Grape(vine) Matte Highliner, Pat McGrath Fetisheyes Mascara, and La Mer Thee Soft Fluid Foundation. I feel sorry for runway models who dont really get much of a choice when someone decides they need to be wearing craft glitter on their eyes on the runway to get a look. In terms of ingredients, theyre using plastic (PET) glitter as well, so theirs doesnt appear different than other uses by makeup brands like UD, MAC, etc. Just the fact that I can feel the gritty texture (no matter how fine) of glitter between my fingers is enough to prevent me from using it on my eyes. Light, Pink, moderately pink undertones. Im already seriously allergic to one FDA-approved pigment color (a diagnosis I learned about through a patch test) so always avoid that pigment color. I have some that I think are really cute from Shroud (formerly Strobe) Cosmetics, but because of concern for my eyes and the difficulty of removal, Ive been using them on my lips. This was honestly a very interesting read! User Agreement and Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement and Want amazing offers and news on the latest consumer brands? I got my item quick and easy since it was my first-time ordering form Colourpop. Under Conclusion or Confusionthe first sentence regarding the FDAs positionare you missing a word there? The duo started ColourPop as an eCommerce business with only 31 shades of eyeshadow to see if people would like them, and they loved their products. Well that was a heck of a rabbit hole you jumped into. Companies can ask for reviews via automatic invitations. Maybe the makeup companies will listen to you. They also don't sell their products where animal testing is required by law. ColourPop Over the Liner Lippie Pencil Review & Swatches We would not have the growing waste and pollution if thought and safety was the standard and priority. Its incredible how very small particles can cause searing pain on the eye so magnified! The U.S. pales in comparison of other countries. Now its fairly ubiquitous. Light Medium, Yellow, slight yellow undertones. However, in looking at your list above and running the ingredients through my database, I see that PET is in quite a few highlighters (I know, not used on eyes, but still, interesting as I wonder if these products can scratch the face) and in one eyebrow product, Fenty MVP pencil. Wow. The product also features denatured alcohol, which can easily penetrate your skin and leave you with a fresh, clean sensation. My understanding is it is (or was) a better method to avoid issues with things like night driving, especially as they are able to work on a larger surface with this method; ergo more tissue is available for treatment. We also ensure all reviews are published without moderation. I found fluorphlogopite in some highlighters; one blush; six shades of ABH Sultry (Pearl, Steampunk, Bloom, Cinder, Teak, Cyborg); and six shades of ColourPop Brown Sugar (Chai, Jamocha, Amber, Ginger, Henna and Choc). As such, you will not develop dry skin, acne, or rash when you use ColourPop products because they are free of toxic and dangerous chemicals. So, the answer is that PET glitter continues to be not approved, and based on my reading of their response, its actually not approved in cosmetics, generally. Nevermind the very large ones that ColourPop insists on putting in their eyeshadow palettes! Is glitter safe for your eyes? Your Guide to Cosmetic Glitter (2020) Ive been wearing heavy eye makeup for over 15 years, and this is the first time Ive gone to an eye doctor because something was stuck in my eye. Im waiting the answer for my request, the package got lost, and I dont know if you send it again, because I have not received the mail back. 3 refills completely fell out of the pallet. Very Light, Olive, neutral undertones. This is so confusing. The CIR also has a report on the safety of certain borosilicate glasses, including calcium sodium borosilicate, which is commonly used in cosmetics, including many favorite sparkly eyeshadows. I think if enough people did and the companies understood clearly just how much business they might be losing, things might change. . Scotch tape to the rescue. Ive really only looked at finished cosmetics vs. raw ingredients, and it seems to turn up as polyethylene terephthalate. Is this post meaning that Lit Cosmetics glitters are in fact no safer than MAC glitters, for example, on the eye? Im very happy with with all of my purchases so far. Ad Choices. The report looked at the potential for ocular injury and found that: Use studies of eye products that contain PET demonstrated no ocular irritation or dermal sensitization. I definitely have to remember to use mine daily! Your skin has pink, peachy pink, or red hues, Your skin has a balance of pink and yellow hues, Your skin has yellow, golden, or olive hues, Free Domestic Shipping on orders over $30, New Lav_ish Collection! Shop Now, Free International Shipping on orders over. Fully agree with this 100%. I am extremely happy not having to wear thick, thick glasses and being able to see at night. This ColourPop concealer review also found that it was created with soft blurring pigments to allow for a crease-proof, matte finish, meaning that you do not need a filter. Products like Stilas Glitter & Glow Liquid Eyeshadows contain plastic glitter in several shades and classic Urban Decay Eyeshadows (seems like most that were described as having micro-glitter) like Chopper, Gunmetal, and Midnight Cowboy (not an exhaustive list) also used PET glitter. Im personally not a fan of the new pressed glitter fad that many brands seem to be pushing, because the particles just seem too big & rough for me to feel comfortable putting near my eyes, even with glitter glue. Also, dont use craft glitter in place of cosmetic-grade glitter! If. Our ColourPop review concludes by recommending this company because it is a reliable brand that offers high-quality products, great deals, and the website provides a good user experience. However, the FDA has a Color Additives and Cosmetics Fact Sheet, and they go over special effects and novelty use, and they included this example (which sounds similar to the example provided in their response in 2012): Composite pigments: Color additives used in combination to achieve variable effects, such as those found in pearlescent products, are subject to the same regulations as all other color additives. I Tried Colourpop's $8 BFF Liquid Eyeliner Pen - Allure I have been using the colourpop foundation gor several years. As adults, we can probably deduce for ourselves that putting chunks of glitter near our eyes has some inherent risks that younger kids wouldnt think about. Its no fun at all. Your eyes never look irritated in your photos, and Ive often wondered how you use and remove so much makeup every day with seemingly no eye or skin irritation. Filter by skin/hair/eye Filter by age. I have never been dissatisfied and will forever support ColourPop cosmetics. Free Shipping at $35. When I recently received a number of damaged items in my order, customer services responded within a day and refunded my order since the items could no longer be replaced. The cream eyeshadow will work perfectly on the inner corner or even along the lashline. I wanted to ask what is the difference between glitter vs shimmer vs foiled vs metallic shadows? Eyelash Glue. Makeup artistKasey Adam Spickard explains that "there are pretty strict guidelines outlined by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) about what is cosmetically eye-safe," which means a product produced for use on your lips may not be safe for use on the eyes. A lot of ophthalmology organizations didnt turn up any results when I tried searching their websites for glitter and/or cosmetics (generally) information or guidance. Lippie Pencil - ColourPop | Ulta Beauty http://thebeautybrains.com/2015/12/should-you-buy-organic-botox-from-kim-kardashian-episode-113/. I have paid much more for shadow palettes and am glad I happened to find this brand. , Make waves with this multichrome blue-violet-teal , Bring the heat with this multichrome bright copper-gold-green , Get the complete Chrome Liquid Eyeshadow collection! Hi Christine have been reading up about ingredients diligently ever since I discovered this post. Then soak my lashes with an additional cotton pad to get rid of the mascara. You would think that it would be easy to ascertain if glitter was safe or if this ingredient was safe for this area or not, but alas, it is not so simple. This pallet duo also comes with The Child Pressed Powder Eyeshadow Palette, a monochromatic palette that contains a variety of finishes from metallic to metallic to ColourPop Cosmetics iconic Super Shock formula. You might inquire with the brand to see if they have a more detailed ingredient list. Quality of eyeshadows is just as good as products that are twice the price. Yes, absolutely, but I manage with constantly applying eye drops. Lip Tints & Balms. Their courteous customer support team is available between Monday and Friday from 8 a.m. 5 p.m. PST, and they will reply to your query within 48 business hours. Excellent value and quality products. Because of my age (advanced) and problems Ive had with my eyes (retinal tears), this whole business of these non-eye-safe glitters is an important one to me but even younger people with healthy eyes well, a lot of them are concerned about this ongoing inclusion of these plastic based glitters in eye products. It's our mission to redefine luxury beauty by creating amazing products at prices that don't break the bank. According to the lawsuit, ColourPop has deliberately and willfully deceived consumers into believing its eye makeup is safe for its intended use. We imagine, develop, test and manufacture all under one roof for next level colour + formulas. Normal-to-Dry skin. no glitter is eye safe. What doesnt make sense to me is why ColourPop would sell an eyeshadow that has the warning not intended for the eye area. WTF!?! Thats what kind of scared me the most about it. This post is so, so amazing, and the reason there need to be people like you reporting thoroughly, critically, and honestly. Dry skin. Thank you for your meticulous investigation! Baby Lotion. 2. Why does one brands Pressed Glitter come with a warning but another brands does not? I cant believe they arent after the cosmetic companies if these products are not approved. With regards to biodegradable glitters (and PET etc for that matter) I hope the FDA will assess the safety of ingesting them in small quantities. I Fell in love with Colorpops powders and lippies! I fangirl when I see you turning on law school mode. Larger glitter or inclusions in makeup can scratch the eye, much like getting sand or dirt in your eye. Customer service takes a long time to reply but they refunded me very quickly although the value refunded was the discounted value of an item from a bundle. Very systematic, referring to precedents, etc. This is the go to brand for me for a reason. PSA: "Not eye safe" glitter lives up to it's warning label Light Medium, Neutral, slight yellow undertones. Can ColourPop lip products be used on eyelids? : MakeupAddiction - Reddit This is yet another example of why you are the best beauty blogger in the blogosphere! BUT, according to the FDA, None of these colors may be used in products that are for use in the area of the eye unless otherwise indicated. I dont see any indication to the contrary so it looks like these two lakes are NOT allowed in products to be used around the eye. Can You Really Use Lip Liner as Eyeliner? | Allure Lip Stain. but Its very much buyer beware. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. It had nearly opaque color coverage in one stroke, which adhered evenly to my lips and was comfortable to apply as a liner as well as all over my lips. Contacted customer service and they would not send it to me even though it was in stock and available and after repeating myself countless times asking why I was unable to get the pallet I gave up. There are some derivatives like polybutylene, but it likely will have terephthalate with it. Eye Shadow. To me, that would imply that an eyeshadow palette being used as an eyeshadow palette should be safe. Im sorry that glitter in the eye happened to you, but so relieved that it turned out ok. Other than a few random blog posts and a Yahoo Answers thread from 2009, there aren't any solid answers. This was a painful reminder to take care and if theres a precaution available, I should take it e.g. Normal-to-Dry skin. Thank you ? These matte shades have the best formula! This post is focused on the first concern as I recently had to go to an eye doctor after-hours to have a plastic particle removed that had gotten stuck to my upper eyelid immediately after I removed my makeup (not during wear) that would not flush out at home. Colourpop's Ultra Matte Lips retail at $6.00 USD for 0.11 oz., just a fraction of the cost of their high-end counterparts. One big concern is that younger persons eager to experiment with make-up, but less aware of any warnings that might (or might not be) on the packaging, will run into a tricky situation because of this. While doing our ColourPop review, we checked some of the products they offer to see how safe they are, the ingredients they use to create them, and who should use them. We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get There are certain ingredients that are prohibited from use, and there are color additives that have limited or restricted use. Alternative ingredients need to be used. Im glad your eye was okay !! ColourPop Eyeshadow, Eyeliner Not Safe for Use Around the Eyes, Class Combination skin. Im thinking that learning about all this is a good way for me to clean out my collection some more. , opalescent white with pink, violet and blue duo chrome effects, Keep cool with this icy lavender with a blue opal duochrome finish , Take a swipe of this white with a icy baby blue flip , A violet with blue and hot pink pinpoints for major looks , Cool off with this icy mauve with a gold flip , The perf pinky lilac with a teal duo chrome finish , An opal with a teal duo chrome finish for the perf glow , A bright true silver and heres the kicker: its gorg , Sing ur heart out with this metallic gunmetal , Cool lavender with blue and gold holographic glitter , Get dewy with this opalescent baby pink , Create the dreamiest looks with this purple trio , Purple vibes are on with this oh so dreamy amethyst palette! Oh my gosh Brenda. If you have any queries about ColourPop or their products, there are several ways that you can contact the support team. The eyeliner has a cartridge of 0.55-ml ink encased in a stylish pen and contains butylene glycol to make the other ingredients spread out in their desired form for use. Some popular products that use one or both that are very sparkly: Pat McGrath Astral Solstice, Kaja Shimmer Trios, ColourPop Eyeshadows, ColourPop Sequin Super Shock Shadow, Hourglass Scattered Light Eyeshadows, MAC Dazzleshadows, and Urban Decay Moondust Eyeshadowsjust to name a few. Eyes. Since the regulation of pigments is so strict for eye makeupand the ingredients are almost identicalyou can theoretically use your eyeliner as lip liner (though I don't know why you would need to when there are about 8 billion lip liners in the world). Rare Beauty Warm Wishes Effortless Bronzer Stick Swatches, Sephora Collection Colorful Blushes Swatches (2023), elf Halo Glow Contour, Highlight, Blush Beauty Wand Swatches, A Pink & Plum Eye Look ft. Sydney Grace x Temptalia, A Tropical Eye Look ft. Sydney Grace x Temptalia, ColourPop x Harry Potter Collection Yer a Disappointment, ColourPop. You use the contact page on their website and describe the issue you are experiencing. Login Private Party ColourPop Bronzer contains talc, which absorbs oil and moisture to prevent caking. They have a few authorized sellers, which can be found on colourpop.com. Lip Gloss. I avoided the obvious ones like ColourPop but didnt realise this applied to the PMG palettes and wouldnt have wasted my money if I knew. Cant even answer a simple question when theyre the ones that messed up. , Our most wearable palette for a super sultry, smoked out eye! The product uses a long-wearing formula, and it features a unique blend of softer powders that adheres to your eyes with ease and gives a soft-focus effect while blending smoothly and evenly. ColourPop offers freebie goodies and promotions throughout the year. Look to see if any shades between two palettes are known dupes. Private Party ColourPop Bronzer helps you get a golden, sun-kissed glow at any time of the year. the use of . Ive bookmarked it for future reference too. and our We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when I've been wanting to try Colorpop for a long time. ColourPop always produces high quality at a fair price. COVERGIRL Exhibitionist Lip Liner, Lip Pencil, Creamy, In the Nude, 0.012 Fl Oz ,Lip Crayon, Lip Makeup, Intense Pigmentation, Self-Sharpening Pencil, Easy Application, Instant Definition 4.4 4.4 out of 5 stars (1,072) Additionally, the product has a silicone-based ingredient called dimethicone that helps retain moisture, gives a silky-smooth texture, and fills wrinkles and lines on your face. So I spoke with two cosmetic chemists to get the factscan you use lip liner as eyeliner and vice versa? All you have to do is customize your routine and create your look. You made my brain hurt reading this. I dont know if it would make much difference to dry eyes (doubtfully), but worth looking into. SHANY Multi-Use Chunky Pencils for Eye Shadow, Eyeliner, Lip Liner, Lipstick - W/Vitamin E & Aloe Vera - Set of 30 Colors. There are alternatives to using plastic glitter, like synthetic fluorophlogopite (which is lab-made mica) and borosilicates, which are two ways Lush replaced plastic glitter in their products, that have widespread usage in cosmetics already. I obviously wanted it. Borosilicate pigments like the Mermaid colors are uniquely reflective. Also, Urban Decay Moondust shadows are in the same category of risk when worn on the eye as say MAC glitter? "I would not interchange these two products, since the one made specifically for eyes was formulated with pigments suitable for eye area," says cosmetic chemist Joseph Cincotta. They even caution against using a lip liner, or any makeup product not intended to be near your eyeball, in that general vicinity (you can read their eye-cosmetics safety guidelines here). "Colors intended for use around the eye have to be specially approved by the FDA.". I think your post will start a much needed revolution in the industry, with regards to Glitter. ColourPop BFF Eyeliner is available in various colors such as white, canary yellow, true black, deep sapphire, dark brown, and bright bubblegum pink. It is more important to notify the FDA of a reaction than the brand as brands are not required to report back to the FDA. Phenoxyethanol is another ingredient in ColourPop BFF Eyeliner, and it is a fixative that prevents bacterial growth. Anyone who is vegan (or indeed anyone) might want to consider that. My personal takeaway from my recent experience and after sifting through what little information was available is to use caution when working with products near or around the eyes, particularly when working with larger particles, whether more traditional sparkle or glitter, and when working with mascara wands (Ive poked myself in the eye at least a dozen times over the years) and brushes (keep em clean!). Lightest, Yellow, slight yellow undertones. This satin-finish bronzer comes in a 7-gram container, and you can apply it onto your jawline, temples, and cheeks for the perfect bronzed look. As others have said, I would never use one of the pressed glitters, but several of the more traditional shades/shadows you mentioned are in my collection! The question is below, and the comment section of the blog has feedback, as well as the podcast. The Panel concluded that modified terephthalate polymers were safe as cosmetic ingredients in the practices of use and concentration described in this safety assessment. (Safety Assessment of Modified Terephthalate Polymers as Used in Cosmetics, April 12, 2013), Within the report, CIR stated, In several use tests of eye shadows, gels, liners, and mascara containing PET (up to 46.272%), there were few reports of adverse effects, including in subjects wearing contact lenses (Table 5). Referring to Table 5 says that there is a very slight ocular irritant potential with the eyeshadow used that is normal for this type of product.. Clearly I dont deliberately eat glitter, but its inevitable that a small amount gets swallowed over the course of talking and drinking and I actually do wear glitter lips semi-regularly. Im always excited to find someone who is from Calgary, Alberta (or who has even heard of it). Not worth it. I think its one thing for a brand to sell individual pressed or loose glitter as a standalone product, but when a brand includes them in a premade eyeshadow palette, it seems like theyre endorsing their consumers to use the glitter on their eyes, even if theres language on the box warning against it not being intended for that use. Im not sure if anyone is still posting to this thread but it seems that synthetic fluorphlogopite is used in many eyeshadows Ive looked up, including my much-loved Sydney Grace. lobstersrcute. I couldnt find much in the way of studies done on PET glitter and whether they were safe for eye usage. ColourPop has a rating of 2.25 stars from 325 reviews, indicating that most customers are generally dissatisfied with their purchases. Normal-to-Dry skin. I live in Europe so it isn't easy to get Colorpop productsI was prepared to pay customs fees of course, I knew I had to. They also confirmed that certain commonly used color additives in Pressed Pigments remain non-permitted for eye area use (I mean, while I was on the line with them, so-to-speak, I figured Id ask!). Yes. You can then subscribe to their newsletter to get updated whenever there is a new deal on your favorite products. I hope youre feeling better now! participate respectfully. I tried eye drops just to see if maybe my eyes were dry or something and they just felt odd. thanks a lot no one is talking openly about it. From the organization American Academy of Ophthalmology, they included the title of a section as avoid glitter eye makeup but go on to say be careful: Be careful with metallic, glitter, sparkle powder or other makeup.
